What is Backlash?
Backlash in gears, fundamentally, refers to the amount of play or gap between mating gear teeth when the direction of load or motion is reversed, [1]. This space allows for the free movement of gear teeth before the opposite tooth faces start to engage. It’s a critical parameter in the design and operation of gear assemblies, acting as a buffer to prevent tooth interference, facilitate lubrication, and accommodate thermal expansion and manufacturing imperfections.
Understanding the true backlash meaning requires recognising its role as a balancing act in gear design. Too little can lead to gear teeth clashing, leading to premature wear, noise, and potential failure. On the other hand, excessive backlash introduces play in the gear train, resulting in lost motion, decreased precision, and a potential increase in vibration and noise.
Thus, backlash is not merely a byproduct of gear design but a critical design element that impacts the functionality, efficiency, and longevity of gear systems.
What Causes Backlash In Gears?
Manufacturing Tolerances & Imperfections
No manufacturing process is perfect, and slight deviations from the ideal dimensions are inevitable. These tolerances and imperfections in gear teeth profiles, pitch, and spacing contribute to the need for backlash. By designing gears with intentional clearance, engineers can accommodate these small inaccuracies, ensuring gears mesh without interference.
Thermal Expansion
Materials expand and contract with temperature changes. In gear systems operating across a range of temperatures, backlash accommodates the expansion of metal components, preventing binding and wear. This consideration is crucial in applications experiencing significant temperature fluctuations, ensuring gears operate efficiently under varying temperature conditions.
Elastic Deformation
Under load, gear teeth flex slightly. This elastic deformation, while typically small, can be significant in high-load applications. Backlash provides the necessary space to allow for this flexure without causing tooth damage or system failure, thereby maintaining the integrity of the gear system under operational stresses.
A Need For Lubrication
Proper lubrication is essential for the smooth operation of gears, reducing friction and wear. Backlash creates the space needed for lubricant to flow between gear teeth, ensuring effective lubrication and cooling of the contact surfaces during operation.
Assembly & Alignment Errors
Even with precision engineering, slight errors in assembly or alignment can occur. Backlash allows for these minor misalignments, ensuring that gears can still engage properly without undue stress on the teeth or bearings, which could otherwise lead to premature wear or failure.
Wear & Tear
Over time, gear teeth can wear down, changing their effective size and shape. Backlash helps to mitigate the impact of this wear, allowing gears to continue functioning effectively for longer periods before maintenance or replacement is necessary.
Backlash in gears is not merely a consequence of design choices but arises from a complex interplay of manufacturing realities, material properties, operational demands, and the inevitable wear and tear of mechanical components. Understanding these causes allows engineers to design more robust and reliable gear systems, taking into account the nuanced challenges of real-world applications.
What does Backlash in Joints or Linear Actuators Mean for Robotic Applications ?
Often backlash is specified in arc minutes or arc seconds. There are 60 arc minutes in one degree and 60 arc seconds in one arc minute. Hence, the relationship between backlash in a joint (specified by theta) and the amount of play x at the end of a robot arm of length L, is given by the formula:
x = theta * L (where theta is given in radians).
For example, if a gear has a specified backlash of +/- 2 arc-min and the arm length is L=1m, then the amount of play will be: x = (2/60) * (pi/180) * 1.0 = 0.00058m or +/- 0.6mm at the end of the robot arm.
For a robot arm with 6 degrees of freedom and many links, the relationship between backlash in the joints and the linear play at the tool center point (TCP) is, of course, more complex and given by the kinematic description of the robot. The amount of play at the TCP is often directly coupled to the parameter “repeatability” given in datasheets of robot models.
Backlash management depends on the application’s precision requirements and control system capabilities. Robot applications that can tolerate backlash include:
- Industrial Assembly Robots: These often handle repetitive tasks with predictable loads, where slight backlash can be compensated for with control systems.
- Material Handling Robots: Used for moving objects, they can often manage minor backlash as precision is less critical than strength.
- Welding Robots: Backlash is tolerable if the weld path adjustments can account for small misalignments.
Robot applications that cannot tolerate backlash are those where high precision is paramount. High-precision machining is one such application. Some robot manufacturers offer robots with specifically low or zero backlash features. Thus, it is important to check the backlash or repeatability in the datasheets of candidate robot models against the application requirements, such as precision, payload, ambient temperature and service requirements (maintenance of gears).
Zero backlash gears are designed to eliminate or minimize the clearance between mating gear teeth, ensuring precise motion transfer. Some methods to achieve zero or low backlash are:
-
Preloaded Gear Systems:
- Split Gears: A common method uses two gear halves mounted on the same shaft, slightly offset and spring-loaded against each other to maintain constant contact with the mating gear. This preload eliminates clearance.
- Dual Pinion Systems: Two pinions engage the same gear, with one slightly advanced and preloaded to remove backlash.
-
Tapered or Conical Teeth:
- Gears with tapered teeth allow for adjustable meshing. By axially adjusting the gear position, the teeth can be brought into tighter contact, reducing or eliminating backlash.
-
High-Precision Manufacturing:
- Tight Tolerances: Gears are machined to extremely tight tolerances using advanced techniques like wire EDM, grinding, or laser cutting to minimize clearance.
- Profile Optimization: Tooth profiles (e.g., involute) are designed with high accuracy to ensure smooth engagement and minimal play.
-
Material Selection:
- Materials with low thermal expansion and high stiffness (e.g., hardened steel or composites) are chosen to maintain consistent meshing under varying conditions.
- Sometimes, one gear is made of a slightly compliant material (e.g., plastic) to reduce backlash while maintaining smooth operation.
-
Anti-Backlash Gearboxes:
- Specialized gearboxes incorporate mechanisms like preloaded springs or magnetic systems to maintain constant tooth contact.
- Harmonic drives or cycloidal drives inherently reduce backlash due to their design.
-
Lubrication and Surface Treatment:
- Low-friction coatings or lubricants reduce wear and ensure smooth operation, maintaining zero-backlash performance over time.
-
Adjustable Center Distance:
- Some designs allow fine-tuning of the center distance between gears to minimize backlash during assembly or maintenance.
Trade-offs of Low/Zero Backlash Gears:
- Increased complexity and cost due to precision manufacturing and additional components.
- Higher friction and wear from constant tooth contact, requiring robust materials and lubrication.
- Potential for over-constraint, leading to increased torque requirements.
These designs are tailored to the application’s precision, load, and speed requirements, balancing cost and performance. Expect to find such methods implemented in high-end robot models and expect them to cost more than models not tailored towards high-end applications.
References
[1] What is Backlash in Gears, https://accu-components.com/us/p/455-what-is-backlash-in-gears, visited on July 27, 2025.